Search
Leave a Message
Thank you for your message. I will be in touch with you shortly.
Explore Properties
A finished white elevated island home beside a clean sandy parcel, framed by palms and coastal greenery in warm afternoon light.

Reading Anna Maria Island's Rebuild Numbers Before You Buy

November 19, 2026

At a Holmes Beach City Commission special meeting on Sept. 9, 2026, the city's Director of Development Services gave his regular update. Holmes Beach had 103 demolitions in total since the 2024 hurricanes, and 33 of those properties held building permits. He had received three more applications for new single-family homes that same day.

That leaves about 70 cleared sites in one island city with no building permit behind them as of mid-September. For anyone comparing homes on Anna Maria Island this winter, that ratio tells you more than a median price does. At the September count, Holmes Beach had plenty of cleared lots and few finished, newly built elevated houses, and those houses were arriving a few permits at a time. Each of the three things a buyer can choose here is priced against that imbalance: an older home that came through the storms, a cleared lot, or a new build.

How the count has moved since Helene

The city's own updates show the gap holding steady through 2026, even though each update counts things a little differently.

Date of update Demolitions or demolition permits New-home permits or applications
Dec. 16, 2025 75 homes demolished, 79 demolition permits 19 permits issued for replacement homes
April 14, 2026 89 demolition permits 30 owners applied for new-home permits
Aug. 25, 2026 104 demolition permits issued 39 applied for new-home permits
Sept. 9, 2026 103 total demolitions 33 demolished properties holding building permits

The December figures come from the Anna Maria Island Sun's Holmes Beach year in review. The April figures come from the city's April 14 meeting packet, which also counted 4,244 permits of every kind issued since Helene. By the Aug. 25 meeting, the city had issued nearly 5,000 permits since the storm.

Over roughly nine months, demolitions grew by about 28 and new-home applications grew by about 20. Rebuilding is happening, and the city keeps processing applications. But the stock of open sites has stayed large, because owners keep clearing damaged homes at about the same pace that other owners file to build.

Bradenton Beach is on the same curve

The pattern continues south of Holmes Beach. The Anna Maria Island Sun reported that at a Feb. 19, 2026 meeting, Bradenton Beach officials said 19 new homes were being built and they expected applications for 19 more empty lots. That is a one-to-one split between homes under construction and lots waiting their turn.

Those empty lots built up over time. By July 2025, Bradenton Beach had demolished 33 hurricane-damaged homes, and officials said older ground-level bungalows were more vulnerable than homes built to current codes, the Anna Maria Island Sun reported that summer.

Taken together, the latest 2026 counts from the island's two southern cities show well over 100 cleared or soon-to-be-cleared sites, and fewer than half of them with a house underway.

Where the new elevated homes are coming from

Raising existing houses is a small part of the picture in Holmes Beach. At the Sept. 9 meeting, staff reported six active Holmes Beach homes in the state's Elevate Florida program and said that number would likely be the city's total unless new funding became available.

Six homes in that program, next to more than 100 demolitions, point to new construction as the main source of the city's next elevated houses. Individual projects show what that looks like. At Seaside Gardens in Holmes Beach, Dospel Construction is building an elevated townhome to replace a ground-level one, and elevation work is underway on one unit each in a duplex and a triplex, the Anna Maria Island Sun reported in March 2026. The city proposed letting owners there voluntarily replace some of the ground-level townhomes with elevated ones.

The north end has its own open lots

The City of Anna Maria has seen less of this, but it isn't untouched. Demolition of the nine-unit Anna Maria Motel at 808 North Bay Blvd. began July 21, 2025. The family that owned it said it planned to sell the property as four vacant lots, according to the Anna Maria Island Sun. Earlier, in November 2024, a storm-damaged single-story home at 709 Fern St. sold for $855,000 on Nov. 8. Its listing described it as sold as-is, with the option to remove the structure and build, or to restore the cottage. That sale is two years old now. It is still an early example of a damaged north-end home priced with a buyer's choice to rebuild or restore built into it.

Anyone planning to build on the north end may want to read a March 2025 report in the Anna Maria Island Sun. Anna Maria's mayor said 40% of permit applications had initially been denied because of incomplete paperwork, and the city had started copying owners directly on contractor correspondence so they could see requests for missing information.

What prices said early, and what the county says now

The first island-level price data after the storms pointed the same direction as the permit counts. In February 2025, the single-family median in ZIP 34217, which covers Holmes Beach and Bradenton Beach, was $1,105,000, down 39% from a year earlier. The condo median there fell 13.7% to $535,000. In the Anna Maria Island Sun's "The new real estate reality," columnist Louise Bolger tentatively attributed the sharper single-family drop to severely damaged, non-elevated houses selling at discounts. She noted that most island condos were elevated and suffered less flood damage. That was an early snapshot. A median also moves with the mix of homes that happen to sell, which is a caution the Realtor Association of Sarasota and Manatee repeats in its own reports.

The broader market has since steadied. In the third quarter of 2026, the Manatee County single-family median rose 3.2% year over year to $490,000, and sales rose 4.2% to 2,017. At the end of the quarter there was 3.9 months of supply, with a median of 49 days to contract and 99 days from listing to closing. In September 2026, the county's condo and townhome median was unchanged from a year earlier at $296,500. Bolger's Nov. 5, 2026 column in the Sun, "Interest rates and normalization," said sellers who need to sell are lowering asking prices and offering concessions such as closing costs or mortgage buy-downs.

Those are countywide numbers. On the island, the city demolition and permit counts are the closest local measure of how older homes and new elevated homes are moving apart.

The three choices on the island this winter

A cleared lot. In Holmes Beach, this is the most plentiful thing on offer, with roughly 70 demolished sites lacking a building permit as of Sept. 9. That supply gives a lot buyer room to compare and negotiate. Buying a lot also means taking a place in the same permitting and construction line that the owners of those 70 sites are already in. A Holmes Beach lot is only worth its price if you are comfortable with the time between closing and moving in.

An older home that came through the storms. These homes have something a cleared lot doesn't: you can use them now. The early 2025 data showed that the market discounted damaged non-elevated houses heavily. The useful question for any particular house is how the market will see it next to the elevated homes going up on its block. The answer depends on the house, its condition and what the buyer plans to do with it.

A new elevated home. By the latest counts, this is the scarce product. On the island's southern half, the supply comes down to the 33 permitted rebuilds in Holmes Beach, the 19 homes Bradenton Beach reported under construction in February, and projects like the Seaside Gardens townhome. A buyer who wants a finished new home is competing for a small number of them. Some of those homes will be built for owners who plan to keep them.

There is one more figure for second-home buyers. Holmes Beach reported 1,611 active vacation rental certificates at its Aug. 25 meeting. Staff also said they would share a map tracking the locations of demolitions and 30-day minimum rentals. Once that map is out, it will show which streets are rebuilding and which already have homes in use.

A few direct questions

Are lots on Anna Maria Island cheaper now? The city counts show there are more cleared lots in Holmes Beach than permitted rebuilds. More supply usually gives a buyer more room to negotiate. What any one lot is worth still depends on its street, its size and what can be built on it.

Is the City of Anna Maria rebuilding at the same pace? The north end's named examples are fewer, such as the four planned lots at 808 North Bay Blvd. Most of the rebuilding counts come from Holmes Beach and Bradenton Beach.

Do the county numbers apply to the island? They show the regional market steadying through the third quarter of 2026. The island's mix of lots, older homes and new elevated builds moves on its own track inside that market.

If you're weighing a cleared Holmes Beach lot against an older cottage or one of the island's new elevated homes, talk with Jesse Griffin about how each choice fits your timeline and budget. You can also see how island homes are valued today or contact Jesse for a personalized market plan.

Follow Us On Instagram